Originally Posted by
deer
10 deerpoints: 3 Michelin star creativity & quality (according to your own judgement)
9 deerpoints: 2 Michelin star creativity & quality
8 deerpoints: 1 Michelin star creativity & quality
7 deerpoints: highly creative food with spices you never tasted before
6 deerpoints: creative food with some real unique dishes
5 deerpoints: very good luxury-hotel food with real local spices
10
FS Hong Kong
9
MO Tokyo
Aman at Summer Palace
RC Wolfsburg
8
Amanfayun
Villa Feltrinelli, Lake Garda
Dolder Grand, Zurich
The Halkin London
FS Florence
FS Istanbul Bosphorus
Regent Berlin
7
Amantaka
Metropolitan London
Metropolitan Bangkok
PH Tokyo
6
PH Saigon
Trisara, Phuket
MO New York
MO München
Como Shambala Estate
Amanbagh
Datai
Setai
Nam Hai
Alila Soori
Originally Posted by
MikeFromTokyo
10 ... Four Seasons George V
7.5 points for Piacere at Shangri-la Tokyo, 7 deerpoints for Nadaman.
6 points for the restaurants of The Peninsula Tokyo
Originally Posted by
Groombridge
Nimb: 9
Dolder Grand: 9
Villa Feltrinelli: 8
George V: 8
Le Meurice: 8
The Connaught: 8
The Dorchester: 8
San Miguel del Allende: 7
Amanyara: 6
Originally Posted by
FlyerEC
Think MOHK is 8
Originally Posted by
nba1017
Berkeley London -- 9
Four Seasons Vancouver -- 8
Elysian Chicago -- 8
Four Seasons New York -- 8
Halkin London -- 7
Ritz Carlton (FS) Chicago -- 7
Four Seasons Dublin -- 7
Four Seasons Washington -- 6
Ritz Carlton New York -- 6
Mandarin Oriental Prague -- 6
Originally Posted by
limelight
park hyatt paris - 6
umaid bhawan palace - 6
Originally Posted by
behuman
Oustau de Baumaniere in Les Baux de Provence with 9 deerpoints
Manoir des Quatre Saisons, Oxfordshire with 9 deerpoints
Inverlochy Castle in Fort WIlliam, Scotland with 8 deerpoints
Auberge du Soleil, Napa Valley with 8 deerpoints.
Originally Posted by
ngfan
Alila Soori: 6 deerpoints
from my second thread >
Originally Posted by
Kagehitokiri
i enjoyed virgin's lodge in verbier, no idea how food would stack up here
Originally Posted by
Kagehitokiri
1. dinner - made to order buffet/club/etc - dim sum/tapas/etc
2. cheapest exclusive-use (private chef) all-inclusive (that is still quality)
obviously very short list, not sure about these, or others
- treetops lodge NZ (if they dont book villas when lodge is booked...)
- singita castleton ZA
- zarafa botswana (wilderness safaris)
im looking at these as much better than accommodations which have private chef included/optional
and assuming existing andbeyond and lebua for example arent worth comparing
re my goal - a "menu" that i can order small dishes / tastes from
isnt it more about three meals a day, rather than 'every restaurant' ? (or at least breakfast and dinner)
with three meals a day, that is where all-inclusive / full board come in...
- amanyara still has free full board offer i think. otherwise there is an exclusive.
- also think CSE is full board only now. edit - theyve changed back again.
(these two properties have 6s above.)
my first thread >
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/luxur...foodblogs.html
of the seven properties that seem best regarded for service here, ive already noticed that they are not necessarily best regarded for anything but service. that includes food, beach, etc. but this is a really interesting thread with scores in that context. (only) two of the seven properties have high scores >
- FS paris - 10 and 8
- pen tokyo - 6
dolder grand and FS bosphorus are also very well regarded here for europe, and they do pretty well in this thread. FS bosphorus and other properties in this thread were also mentioned by
vuittonsofstyle in my second thread. same with FS HK for asia.