FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - East Bali Hotels
View Single Post
Old Jul 15, 2011 | 11:38 pm
  #17  
Makanmata
10 Countries Visited20 Countries Visited30 Countries Visited20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: NYC, GIG
Posts: 336
Originally Posted by namaguide
I quite disagree with you Vuittonsofstyle. At Aman I would expect that you should have to ask them to prepare something special. Clearly a menu of 5 options for each course cannot really cater for long stays. At Amanpulo when I stayed for two months the chef was preparing a different daily menu for us of 3 options for each course after the first week of stay - and we even did not have to ask for it! I think it is all a matter of managing expectations and understanding intelligent accommodation.
By far my least favorite aspect of Amankila is the food -- indeed the only aspect that I am never more than minimally satisfied with. I think that Amankila is very accommodating, and they will indeed prepare anything you might want, so its not really a lack of variety that is the issue -- though you will notice a regular routine if you order from the menu (if its Tuesday it must be Lamb Gulai Java). The problem for me rather is that they aim for a very safe, "middle of the road" food program, which is intended to be neither offensive nor exciting for anybody. Personally, while I love the atmosphere of the restaurant as well as most any place on earth, the food is anything but exciting, or even interesting. Amankila is in no way like a regular hotel, except that they serve regular hotel food, in a locale where the cuisine and ingredients call for something much more exciting. The buffet barbecues and such are particularly poor I think, resembling to me ordinary mass catering.

And they aren't aiming for exciting either, and not looking to take advantage of the wealth of excellent products offered in Bali. I recall a conversation with a now departed chef about how he wasn't able to prepare us a whole fish, as the only fish they generally served were fillets, as they needed to procure the fish all the way from Jimbaran, and only fillets could make the long trip without spoiling. Local fish suppliers he said, were not suitably reliable, and besides, the guests don't want to eat a whole fish with a head on it anyway. I was surprised by this attitude, as I know that -- particularly in a place where the seafood is so excellent -- I absolutely want a fish with a head on it, and not antiseptic filets like I could get in Indianapolis or Eindhoven. Moreover, I would have hoped that over the years they would have made more of an effort to source things locally, or to figure out how to transport produce better so as to increase the quality of the food. In any case, the food at Amankila has little sense of place in my opinion, and there is no local version of Pak Parno nearby like they have at Amanjiwo (where I am happy to eat every night). So for me its not an issue of variety, but rather an issue of Amankila -- and Aman generally -- having a food program that is just not as ambitious or sophisticated as the rest of the hotel.
Makanmata is offline