Originally Posted by
Emma1420
However, I also think that there should be a size check as part of security process. If you carry on bag doesn't fit in the size guide at security then you asked to check the bag. And I also think that there need to be size guidelines about the personal item. I think providing specific dimensions for the personal item (like they do with the carryon item) and then enforcing those dimensions would help significantly. Because I've seen plenty of people carry huge purses or bring on a bag as a personal item that can not really be put in the seat in front of them.
They tried this at IAD a few years ago. All the xray machines had templates that blocked anything over the size allowed by UA for carryons. A number of the other airlines sued to have it removed and they prevailed. I think at that point TSA washed their hands of it and in effect said it's the airlines problem.
The airlines don't really seem to care about the issue as they either get extra revenue out of baggage fees or use the extra space in the in cargo compartment to fly cargo. They keep their premium passengers happy by waving the fees and allowing priority boarding, giving them first access to the overheads. And yes I am very happy they do this. I'm only 5'6" but I like my leg room too!