I have never considered NCL or most of the others. Usually sail Seabourn, a very different product and milieu. However, I think the itinerary will be terrific, and am doing Quebec to NYC in later September. Can't wait for all the lobster!!
I think many can be naysayers. Ignore us and have fun, making up your own experience with new ideas about cruising. There are plenty of lines and itineraries from which to choose. No matter, I don't think this cruise will be your last!!