I also find the Davies Gate Quince (also provided at Courtyards) barely passable. The funny thing is that they used to give out Davies Gate Quince at some of the Park Hyatt properties, and I remember it being pretty nice. Perhaps there is something different (i.e. cheaper) in the formulation with what is offered at RI and CY? (For example, I believe Four Points still offers toiletries from Casswell-Massey, but it's really bad and nothing like "real" CM products.)