In my opinion, babies should be banned in all J and F cabins. If I had it my way, they should be banned in ALL cabins.

You cannot control the cries of babies, unless you drug them. If it is not controllable, they should not be allowed to disturb other people.

If an adult was wailing like a baby with the high pitched screams, he would be offloaded. This is a behavior that disturb other pax. But if a baby did this, it would be deemed natural or uncontrollable. This doesn't make it right.

IMO, babies could be allowed if the parents agree to have them drugged or sedated whenever a wailing episode happens or about to happen.

Kudos to MH for starting this. This is a great start!!!!^