Nologic.The rates you quote,are they US dollars?Sounds high for the Vogue and low for the Ritz.
I agree with Fisch,especially being closer to old Montreal.There are many great restaurants there.Your concierge will be able to suggest the trendiest at the moment.During my last visit to YUL,we were in a quaint trendy restaurant, at a window seat.All arranged within 4 hours of dinner by the concierge.They can work wonders.