FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Is the UK the only country where body scanner opt-out = you can't fly?
Old Jun 15, 2011 | 6:43 am
  #14  
Frog Escalator
 
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Sussex, England
Posts: 59
So the UK is in good company with (anecdotally) the Ukraine and Kazakhstan in denying a choice in this.

There was a good albeit understated quote in [UK human rights organisation] Liberty's response to the Department for Transport 19 July 2010 consultation on the body scanners:

(Helen Mountfield QC and Professor Conor Gearty, Matrix Chambers, who gave their advice on this issue):

“If a person were compelled to consent to any form of search as a condition of flying, whenever the requirement to undergo it was introduced, however intrusive it may be, however discriminatory, and however arbitrary and unjustified, there might come a point where the consent could not be held to be ‘true consent’…”
(Comes up first in a Google search for "consultation 19 July scanners liberty"
I have looked for the outcome of that consultation that closed on 19th July last year, but can't find it. I would write to my MP (who's the only Green MP in the country, however, and who is likely utterly opposed to aviation full-stop) to see if she can ascertain why only the UK out of every other western country (barring Ukraine and Kazakhstan) deems it absolutely necessary to deny access to a flight (even if you also consent to a manual search, or even a strip search) if you refuse to be zapped. This ruling was put in place hurriedly in the dying days of the previous government, but the current government doesn't seem in a hurry to reverse it.

It's quite tragic, as I've noted on other forums, how people so readily accept this treatment. I can sympathise, however, given the arm-twisting option of "forgo your business trip/hard-earned holiday or go through this machine. It's your choice". I think London City Airport and even Southampton are now attractive options to Gatwick (I can see these machines being expanded to the South Terminal soon also without any announcement) ...

Frog Escalator is offline