During the time when I was at Amangiri, the resort was full and it indeed revealed the design flaw in the openness of the public space. The noise at breakfast was certainly not the usual aman experience and it make the use of the library impossible. Also the staff to guest ratio is not as high as the other Asian Amans so the service could be compromised. There were several times I have to wait to talk to the concierge because they were engaged with the other guests. While the activities are expensive, I highly recommend the Hummer tour which cost less than 500.