FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - [Consolidated] 1099s for miles & cash rewards from all banks
Old Apr 15, 2011, 12:45 pm
  #84  
dhuey
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
 
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Berkeley, CA USA
Programs: Piggly Wiggly "Shop the Pig!" Preferred Shopper
Posts: 57,084
Originally Posted by flyerfrog
I just spoke with IRS agent for 1099-INT and here's what I found out.

According to one of their publications (i think she said it was 550), the value of the gift is determined by the cost to the financial institution.
IRS phone agents are wrong about 1/3 of the time, and this one is here -- at the very least, what she is saying is highly misleading. What matters is the fair market value of the miles. That's not so easy to determine with FF miles because the rules of the program prohibit the free exchange of the miles. Nevertheless, there are mileage brokers out there, and miles are being bought and sold left and right. In my opinion (rely on it at your own risk), this market is the best way to determine miles' fair market value.

Of course Citibank's cpm is not $0.025 -- that's roughly the retail price at which airlines will sell their miles to you. Another inappropriate measure is the liability airlines record on their books for the miles. That's a tiny amount that merely reflects the extra cost of having an extra person show up on a plane for free.


Originally Posted by flyerfrog
In the response to my request for an amended 1099-INT that I sent to citibank, they never gave me an explanation of their cost.
That's highly proprietary information; no way will Citibank release that.

Originally Posted by flyerfrog
The agent also told me, if you believe your 1099-INT is incorrect, and you have not been able to have it corrected by the financial institution, you are allowed to use your own estimate for the 1099-INT amount.
This one she got right. If you are reporting a lower interest amount than on a 1099-INT, it's a very good idea to include a statement at the end of your return explaining the difference. If you don't you will probably get an automated request for either a correction or explanation.

Originally Posted by flyerfrog
I'll be using my estimate of miles valuation at $0.005, which lowers my 1099-INT amount to $25 from $125.
That's too low. It's about 20% of the retail price and less than half of what you see with the mileage brokers. I've used $0.015 recently.
dhuey is offline