I'm looking for a great place for my father's birthday dinner (for 5 people) in May. Of course we'd love a place that has it all -- beautiful setting, great food. I'm not concerned about the price but am definitely after a place that's genuinely delicious. A picturesque spot would be great, but we don't want to be somewhere beautiful where the food is bland. Really looking all over the place right now -- Roy's, Duo or Spago at the Four Seasons, Lahaina Grill, Merriman's, open to anything. Really just looking for the right spot.

I'd so appreciate your feedback. Thank you!