Just got everything finalized for my first year wedding anniversary.
We will be spending 6 nights in Bora Bora!! Ended up using AA miles for the trip to PPT, and Hilton points for the hotel. I did pay $250 to upgrade to an Overwater Bungalow for 3 of the nights, and they gave me a free upgrade to a Hillside Villa for the other three. Most expensive part was having to buy the tickets from PPT to Bora Bora which were $400 each.
I wanted to make this vacation spectacular, as my wife will hopefully be starting law school this fall, so no vacations for 3 years as law school is expensive...too expensive if you ask me