FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - you have the right to remain silent
View Single Post
Old Dec 9, 2010 | 6:23 pm
  #20  
LessO2
FlyerTalk Evangelist
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 10,034
Originally Posted by richard
there are two officials. I don't care that they work for the same entity. One is immigration, the other is customs.

Customers can search you and I get that.

Immigration people are law enforcement officers whose job is to ascertain if you are allowed into the United States.

Once I present my passport, I'm done with them. I don't have to answer their questions. I don't like to and I don't have to. I'm wondering how to elegantly refuse without getting subject to temporary detention and upsetting my fellow travelers.

And a question like "did you bring anything back?" can only be answered with either 1) another question such as "like what?" or 2) an answer like "nothing" on the assumption that the question being asked is "did you bring anything back that you purchased from that country you came from and that we should know about" but that technically is a lie.

You see? This is a problem. You can't get around it. What's the solution?

READ the OP cite carefully, please. It tells me that if I assume something is being asked that is not being asked, I can be lying to a federal official and I am committing a crime, let alone that what I say can be used against me.
Again, just answer honestly.

If you're looking at picking a fight, just say so....the conversation you are seeking would be much more fruitful rather than this dancing around nonsense you're doing.
LessO2 is offline