I really dropped the ball in not keeping this up over the last few months, but here's what I've gotten on my recent YYZ rentals. This should give you an idea of what's out there.

Sep 1
Terminal 1
Booked: Premium
Offered: Chrysler 300 by greeter, said I needed something with cargo space, allowed to take an SUV for the same price
Drove: Ford Escape XLT w/leather

Sep 2
Terminal 1
Booked: Premium
Drove: Lincoln MKZ AWD (Luxury), parked on Exec row

Sep 10
Terminal 1
Booked: Premium
Drove: Lincoln MKZ AWD parked on Exec row (I believe there were other choices that day but I was allowed to take the MKZ for no upcharge)

Oct 12
Terminal 1 (After midnight - aisle closed, counter service)
Booked: Premium
Offered: Chrysler 300, asked for a Ford product as I was going to Oakville Ford plant the next day
Drove: Lincoln MKX with 20" chrome rims (Premium Elite)

Oct 25
Terminal 3
Booked: Fullsize
Drove: Ford Explorer in Fullsize stall

Nov 3
Terminal 3
Booked: Fullsize
Drove: Ford Taurus SEL on Emerald Aisle

Nov 17
Terminal 1
Booked: Fullsize
Drove: Nissan Maxima in Fullsize stall

Nov 30
Terminal 3
Booked: Fullsize
Drove: Nissan Maxima on Emerald Aisle