SH is the best of the 3 there, and I've stayed at all 3 on different trips, although I really don't think either of the properties will disappoint, though it's been about 3 years since I stayed there, as I now stay at the JW when I'm in Orlando - LOVE that place. I've found room rates there of $99.00 a night for some nights, so check out when you're planning on staying there (LPR Code), as sometimes you can get a great, great deal there and the lazy river the JW has is great for kids.