Originally Posted by
Blumie
My gf and I were on our way to Roberta's, in Bushwick, but made a quick stop at a bookstore in Greenpoint on the way. Walking around the neighborhood, we stumbled upon
Paulie Gee's and decided to give it a try instead of Roberta's. We loved it! We rank it ahead of Keste and Motorino (but still behind Co.) in our rankings of NYC pizza.
The best part of the meal was that we were undecided between the Delboy pizza and one of the pizzas with arugula on it. We asked if we could do a half-and-half, but Paulie thought that wasn't a good idea, so we ordered the Delboy. After we finished it, Paulie came over and delivered an Arugula Shmoogula pie on the house! It was an awesome gesture! ^
Roman or Neapolitan?
Originally Posted by
Blumie
Yes, including a decent beer list.
Sorry you were disappointed. I think Co. is the best pizza in NYC right now.
It depends on your definition of pizza, I suppose! A good friend of mine tells me it's not traditional pizza.
