Originally Posted by
Awesom Andy
I did... although admitedly, it was a promo fare that was around the same price as the discount economy fare from other full service airlines flying that route.
Depending on how long the flight is, if they ever approach me for a downgrade, I probably would've counter offered them with $300.

You misquoted what I said. I said if everyone could buy a discount economy fare, and upgrade cheaper in advance than buying a Starclass fare outright, no-one would buy Starclass up front.
I've bought a number of Starclass fares, at full cost, because they are so cheap anyway, and I'm not playing the ODU lottery at check-in.