I don't know.. I've eaten at both restaurants and the experiences were both enjoyable, but very different. I think if I were to chose for another evening, I might go with GDs partly because of the location (FL is just waaay out of the way), and partly because it's a bit more relaxed feeling.

But honestly at the level this list is talking about, you should have a wonderful experience whether you go to the top five or the bottom five... they should be exemplary, both in food and dining experience.