Originally Posted by SteveF

If you are in a Water Villa you get the cocktails anyway, so go for option 1 (obviously). If you are not in a water villa it depends on how much value you put on the cocktail hour (5-6pm) where beer, red and white wine and the cocktail of the day are free. Bear in mind that the (excellent) breakfast is $35 + 10% and the value of drinks range from about $8 (beer) to $15 (cocktails), again + 10% of course. We were in a water villa both times so the issue did not arise for us, but if we had to choose we would probably go for the cocktail hour and have one breakfast delivered to our villa (my wife is not a big breakfast eater anyway) and eat it on the villa's sun deck. If you both eat breakfasts then the question is: can you drink $75 worth in one hour? We could (and did)!