Last stay I had at the Hyatt Arlington had a slightly different variant of the toothpaste, without the Hyatt logo customization and orange rather than gold colouring on the box.

Not sure about the value of the items in the catalog, though I recently did use some of my Aeroplan miles to buy a hotel bedding kit on offer. And I must say, having the extra undersheet duvet as well as the regular bed cover duvet does make for a more comfortable bed. Plus all those pillows!