We Noo Yawkers look down our noses at anything from Jersey

.
CO has a couple of factors against it in my situation:
* No SFO-CN flights at all (all operated by UA). Since half my departures will be from SFO that makes things a bit wonkier.
* $75 cab ride from EWR to Brooklyn, where I'll be staying. I've done the NJTransit/Penn Station/MTA route-- no way I'm doing that after 24 hours of travel.
* I'm going to have to fly Y quite a bit--I can't make a decision solely on the C experience. How's the Y on TPAC?