Originally Posted by
OliverB
I was actually just looking at the Mauna Kea, as well as the St. Regis Princeville.
While the website looks gorgeous, I've seen a few photos of rooms on tripadvisor that are slightly worrisome. I understand the hotel was recently renovated so perhaps these were from pre-renovation. I'm still not 100% satisfied with all options so far... I want something really exotic that feels like a Pacific island hideaway. I'm not a fan of large resorts, I don't like to feel like I'm staying at a golf course.
Is Waikiki really that busy and commercial?
Are there any nearby private islands that are not owned by Four Seasons, Fairmont, Starwood, etc? I still haven't found the ideal place... although if the Royal Hawaiian were situated on another island in a more remote setting, I'd probably go with that. I'd even be open to villas, beach bungalows, etc. Something different and more exotic than these other accommodations.
You may want to consider Kona Village Resort on the Big Island. Our most recent experience was less than stellar. However, if you specifically request NH 4 or 5 as your Hale you should be fine. The property is beautiful. Very Hawaiian. I suspect you will really like this property but you have to make sure that you get the very best hale. Moreover, there are promotions being offered, so check those. Beware:Only reserve a specific hale. Kona Village Resort loves to sell "ocean view, front, garden, blah, blah, blah."
Do not settle for less than New Hebrides 4 or 5. You will pay a king's ransom, but it will be the Hawaiian experience you have always dreamed of.