Back when I used to frequent this forum, trolls occasionally started threads of this nature just to stir the pot. The objective was to get UA flyers to concede that their airline was way behind the curve up front.

As much as I've grown to like some of the better Asian airlines (since I've stopped flying UA), the grass isn't much greener in the biz cabin. And, now that UA biz features those flat seats that I have yet to experience myself, I'm guessing that the playing field is level (as long as UA's FAs aren't downright mean).

With regard to F, even if UA's 2010 version is twice as good as its 2008 version, there's simply no comparison.