Great report,
Ericka! Nice to hear what it's like inside - we just returned from PLS and only got to see the resort from our dive boat offshore.
At one dive site, there is a deck chair on the reef at the top of the wall - the dive guides joke that it's the only thing they were able to sneak out of Amanyara.
And yes, the diving was superb - we saw turtles on every single dive we did there at Northwest Point. ^