Originally Posted by
slidergirl
I didn't really think of the Porter as a backpack. I thought of it more as a suitcase with straps. The lack of a frame is not an issue. I didn't notice that at all (and I've had framed packs in the past). The reasons I picked the Porter were: 1) doing lots of trains and stairs and cobbles, so wheels wouldn't be very useful 2)wheels would take up space that I could use for items 3)the Porter was lighter than the Waypoint.
I looked at the MEC website when I saw you were in Canada. Yeah, they didn't have the Osprey. While you're there, checkout their own brand of a similar bag if they have one. I'm always impressed with the quality of the MEC products.
This is exactly how I feel/want. I would like a bag that is more of a suitcase than a backpack. If I want a backpack backpack, i will get a backpack
I ordered today a "Port Red" Osprey Porter 46, I look forward to receiving it. I think I will just bite the bullet and get the 65 right away.
All three points you mentioned above I will be encountering this coming trip as well.
I didn't end up going to MEC today. I agree they do have good things...the first time when I went to do some re-con work I tried out the bag (Deuter), and it did feel nice, but I think the Porter will be the overall winner.