Originally Posted by
lancebanyon
I only gained status on AC for the first time last year after many years on UA. The other day I took my first TATL on AC and was very pleasantly surprised to be summoned from my coach seat before takeoff to be upgraded. In 15 years of TATL flights on UA I can honestly say that no one ever came to get me from coach to upgrade me.
Got an opup. That is, you were lucky. Having status with AC, I have had opups with United, with LH, with SK. Actually, only time I was already in Y but got pulled to business was on United... (On AC I never do get one. I usually find a way to sit in front ahead of time.)
I don't think this makes one airline better than the other, really more a matter of them needing Y seats but having J seats left.
Good to take anyway.