We stayed here 3 nights this past weekend. All was perfect. The Renovations appear to be complete. Only a few Tube TV's are still being replaced with Flat Screens. We never turned the TV on. Upgraded to Ocean Front Room. Nice Balcony , overlooking the SunSet Pier. The Glass Doors leading to the Balcony were Super Sound Proof. Although we left the door open most of the time.
In my opinion , this is the best location in Key West. Did not rent car. Taxi flat $8 per person from airport. Walked everywhere. Staff warm and welcoming. WE will go back .