Is the new fixed-back shell Y seat really that bad? I heard a lot of my friends complaining about it and wanting to switch to other airlines programs just because of the new Y seat.
Quote:
Not really, I think that it's an upgrade from previous seats, the only problem is the thin cushion padding

Couple more questions:
Since the new Y seat doesn't recline, do you still need to adjust your seat to upright position during take off and landing?
Quote:
Yes

If the reclining is done by sliding the seat cushion forward, does it decrease the leg room?
Quote:
It does decrease the leg room but it is worth having; due to the person not reclining into your space

Do you sleep better or worst with the new Y seat?
Quote:
My flight from HKG-LHR was a midnight flight so it was easier to sleep but what surprised me was that I slept for 9 hours straight and only 2 hours till landing

Do you think the new Y seat is the worst design ever in airlines industries?
Quote:
It isn't the best or worst but it is a new design idea, the J class was a let down but it's still an upgrade. I think the worst is the current BA and Air China Y seat