Originally Posted by
Trollkiller
Technically illegal? I would bet more times than not.
Any search that was caused by ID or lack thereof would be illegal. Any search that was initiated without alarm would be illegal. Any search that was initiated because the TSO saw something on the x-ray that it was known the object was not a WEI would be illegal. Any search that continued after the alarm was cleared would be illegal.
I disagree with some of what you say. If someone does not have ID I think it is very reasonable to search that person and their property. I believe you agreed with this, before? Has your opinion changed since Gilmore (I believe your stance was allow someone not to show ID and allow them to be screened as a selectee).
What is an "alarm"? That's very vague. The x-ray never alarms, ever. The person working the x-ray sees something, or can't see something (think clutter, or something very dense). What do you call an alarm on the x-ray considering there is no actual alarm, but only the interpertation of th. X-ray operator, people who may very well see different things looking at the same image?
What if a person checking the bag "alarms", not for contraband, but another possible prohibited item or an WEI? At one point checking a bag I was going for one item in a multi-pocket briefcase when what might have been a knife poked me through the fabric of another pocket which the x-ray operator did not see. There were many cables in the bag. At that point I can honestly say that I wondered if the bag was too cluttered to be x-ray screened properly, and searched the compartments of the bag for other prohibited items and possible WEIs - not contraband. Was the fact that my search continued beyond the original item illegal? ccording to fofona, it was not.