This weekend I flew to STL on AA, and then home today on WN. Most of my flying is on AA, mostly in F when on mainline, so like most of you I have some great experiences and many average ones.
The very clean WN plane was remarkable, as was the deadheading pilot who was actually helping the flight crew, and the crew cleaning as we deplaned. Our flight was full and bags had to be gate checked, but we still arrived on time.
I'm used to AA EXP upgrades, etc., but WN really isn't a bad experience at all.