Last year I gave 3p to a co-worker instead of my wife because she always flys with me. Long story short she flew over to visit me in China and also alone to MCO to visit family. Both on F saver tickets but both had short hops that did not have F space and she would have ended up in E-. Imagine flying home from PVG in new config first and then doing ORD BDL in E- at the time of booking there was plenty of E+ seats and I called 1k but she did not qualify. She ended up staying an extra day in Chicago as she was spending a few days there visiting friends already and they had space in F the next day.
She got my nomination this year.