I am in the same situation as you and wondering if it is worth making the extra effort to reach Platinum. I have just made Gold and have been disapointed. I concur with one of the responses that the Staff do not seem to know the rules. I have never been upgraded and have found, since making Gold six weeks ago, that I have to ask for access to Concierge. I agree that Marriott's are by and large consistent but not in the Gym. Hilton is now offering exercise equipment in the room itsef. I sometimes feel that Marriott Staff takes us for granted and that service is varying more and more. Having said that I can personaly recommend the Northern Kentucky Airport Marriott - best service ever at a Marriott. I will not be trying for Platinum although it is doable for me. I will now balance out with Hilton.