I was fetching a car when
Flying Chef was posting about it.
About 8AM Oct 10th (Saturday morning) - both aisles pretty well-stocked with the usual suspects. Nothing excessively luxurious on either aisle.
ES had a few Impalas, one of those boxy SUV's (Matrix?), a Charger, and a couple of Altimas. I was looking for a Volvo, based on this thread.

Alas, no Volvos. One of the Altimas was a hybrid - I took that one.
I didn't pay too close attention to the EA but it was completely full of cars...mostly the standard stuff.
The "Executive VIP" section had two nice Lexuses sitting there. I'm almost embarrassed that I don't know this, but how many rentals/days are required to hit that status? EWR is the first location I've seen with a sign indicating Exec VIP. I've rented National at other NYC locations, plus SFO, IAD, ORD, and other big U.S. locations.