The YX we knew and loved has been dead for many years. While certainly Tim protected his hiney, it's difficult to tell whether he was a willing accomplice in its demise or another victim. YX was essentially killed off the moment is strayed from its core values and service.

That said, I believe there is a place for Republic to rebuild but it may be too late.

The E190 and E170 had potential to revive the old YX -- leather seats, two across (albeit a bit smaller) for everyone. Chef catered meals which could be purchased with the ticket. No baggage fees. Flexible change options. Outstanding customer service.

I think Republic could counter the LCC's by offering reasonable fares with a meal purchase option and exceptional service. Would you rather fly cattle car Southwest or your hometown airline, etc.?