You always make me smile when you lapse into the SA vernacular.

I don't think anybody is arguing against the concept of the site. But unless there is some sense that the relative ratings are consistent and impartial, one has to question what is driving their decisions. Commissions, maybe?

It is a handy resource just as a listing of what is available (though why do they even bother with an arbitrary sprinkling of city listings?). One can then do more research elsewhere before committing.