Originally Posted by
moondog
For historical blurbs, buy a history book (though dated, In Search of Modern China remains one of my favorites).
At the risk of triggering a full-on essay in rebuttal from our resident guidebook editor, I'm going to plug Lonely Planet because I really like it. While useless with respect to things like 5-star dining, it has helped me form effective game plans in second and third tier cities many times over the years, which is a weak point for many of the higher brow guide books. A drawback that Peter has pointed out in other threads is that some content is over 20 years old (which is a substantial length of time in a country that is undergoing 8% growth). But, for the most part, it still works quite well. BTW, I also relied on LP when I was living in India during the late 90s and it was effective there as well.
A 700 plus page book by Spence (albeit fantastic - currently working through it) for blurbs? My thinking was more like a few pages (at most) of history and descriptions with some photos of the major sites, like the Forbidden City, which LP and others (they have to cover more things) may skimp on.
I actually think LP is ok for the basics, its what I use it for (a guideline) and all I need.