FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - The top wines in your cellar
View Single Post
Old Sep 8, 2009 | 6:41 pm
  #164  
D1andonlyDman
Suspended
 
Join Date: May 2008
Location: San Diego
Posts: 3,723
Originally Posted by Gaucho100K
Well... if you endorse them then that is saying a lot... but, IMHO if I were you and you were in the market for some of the high-end wines by the glass at this place, it would be interesting for the Sommeliere to explain (in detail) what their SOP regarding high-end juice by the glass is... and I reiterate, in detail...

In my book, no high-end and/or full service place should be caught dead with an opened bottle that is longer than 12 hours old** - no matter how sophisticated any vacuum or inert gas preservation system is.

(**) unless this is part of a very specific double-decant scheme, etc. etc.
I disagree with this. IMHO, young top-tier ageworthy wines that are put on an inert gas preservation system improve for at least 2-3 days, and often as long as 4-5 days if the wine really needed to be open for a few hours to open up. Obviously, if a we're talking with a wine with 10-20 years of bottle age on it, drinking it sooner is better, but most better restaurant wine lists are full of things like 4-5 year old red Bordeaux and recent vintages of California Cabs or Burgundies, or similar quality stuff from other places - but it's mostly current releases - and all of these wines could use a bit of exposure to air. If I'm drinking a 5 year old classified growth Bordeaux, or a 3-4 year old California Cabernet or Argentine Malbec, or Aussie Shiraz, I'd prefer to drink it after it was on a gas system for 2 days, as opposed to 2 hours. It would certainly be nice to know about how long it had been opened if that info was available - but my issue with most restaurant wine lists, particularly those laden with top-notch reds, is that the wines are served too young, and without enough airing. Putting a bottle on an inert gas system that might last 2-5 days in a typical restaurant setting when served by the glass actually improves this situation - sometimes noticeably.
D1andonlyDman is offline