Not much of a choice these days on the route I'm afraid, not if you want to fly direct anyway...
The only direct flights are with CY, unless you want to travel with RJ vie AMM or with OA vie ATH, which really makes no sense at all on such a short flight.

I think Arkia fly at certain times of the year but not sure when and not sure they fly to LCA, I think it might be PFO.

CY are fine but I do miss the days LY flew the route.