Originally Posted by
magiciansampras
My vision wasn't so much that this would generate debate about particular threads, but rather T B members would create something of a laundry list of good ones.
But for each thread, given that there are 9 TB members you are bound to hear, oh, 28 or so different opinions about the relative merits of each and every thread. No, really, many TB members have 3-4 different opinions about each and every issue!
Seriously though, achieving consensus on a single thread much less consistency across the universe of threads would be virtually impossible.
When you first suggested this, I thought about maybe some standards or guidelines for identifying 'threads of excellence' but even there I can't come up with any rational objective measure.
So.
I understand your goal but I can see no way to achieve it.