Ouch - I guess there's no real reward in loyalty, then, as I haven't heard the greatest things about Avis First. I have no intention of signing up for another credit card (I already have three and like to keep it at that), so for now I created an entirely new Avis profile using the link from the CO Presidential Plus page, but as of yet it just lists me as a preferred member. No problems in signing up, at least; if at some point it updates the page to say that I'm PC, I'll just cancel all of my reservations on the old profile and make them again on the new one.