Do you think Toledo (and the Toledo Hilton?) are worth a trip of their own? Or is it worth staying at MAD (and likely pay less/use fewer points) and make it a day trip?
It is all up to you and your own situation.
On this trip, I just didn't want to pack & unpack too often. Besides, I know a day trip to Toledo is simple and easy, without having to rush.
That said, if I was on "matress-run", need more stays, then I would add Toledo Hilton for that reason.
I do think Toledo is worth a trip. It has plenty to offer. If I had the time, I would have spend 2 days there, and perhaps a stay overnight.