Hi Peterpack, because of the Diamond status, I get superb treatment at the GH and PH, but my favourite Melbourne hotel is the Sofitel. I, too find the Crown a little too glitzy, as a tourist I would suggest you live in the CBD, and dine over on the Southbank where your preferred hotels are both located. It's all within easy walking distance, with the Art's precinct and the Yarra River in between. CBD shopping is huge and the strip shopping in close by suburds is very trendy, enjoy your stay