We spent two nights there last week. As a PLT I was upgraded to a "Fabulous" room which was fairly small, but large according to W standards.
Staff was great, restaurant great, all in all a nice hotel if you are into the whole W thing.
Personally, at 48 years old, I feel 20 years too old for any W property. The whole bar scene and all is just not me, but since they canned the St. Regis and Atlantic from *wood in FLL, I am at the W. And I am HAPPY to be there because the other choice is the Yankee Crapper up the street.
So, I say, YEAH for the W FLL.