There is a new Hilton at Tobago. We have not been but, also being from CA, do like the Caribbean for variety. Tobago has terrific beaches. A Point Stretcher award is available June 1 - 17. Food is really interesting - we have stayed at the Trinidad Hilton, no beach. En route by car to the main beach, we stopped for roti sandwiches at a roadside stand, met our US Ambassador who was there with his family! There was a poet man who made up a long poem for both families!!
Last summer, we stayed at the very new St Lucia Hyatt (really cheap grand opening rates and upgrades). I also recommend the St Lucia Jalousie Hilton - had lunch there. They have a free shuttle to town. It is a renovated hotel, rather than new. Gorgeous setting between two mountains, cottages, and better beach than Hyatt (need beach shoes there because of the coral).
You need to break out of the Hawaii box. Water is warmer in the Caribbean and snorkeling is terrific. Your kids will love it. If you do go to Hawaii, why not Waikoloa on Kona instead of Maui so your kids can swim with the dolphins?
[This message has been edited by Karen2 (edited 04-29-2001).]