So are they querying the fare buckets when you search from the fare catcher e-mail? Or just pulling over Orbitz pricing?
On a quick check, It brings up a different calendar than usual with the various pricing available on those dates. Make your selections and then FC dumps you to Orbitz which actually prices it out.
Also, The fare display tool is still down!! Please bring that back if you would.
http://www.farecompare.com/fare-display/index.html