Am I the only one that notice that MRTC is no longer existent on AA. They have moved several of the rows back in on certain aircrafts according to a report I recently read. That is why they are no longer using that slogan or they are just saying "More Room" not "More Room thoughout Coach."
For the infrequent traveller, I think WN offers the best service and FF benefits. Just fly 4 RT in a year and get a free ticket. The RT can be short segments between destinations in FL, TX or longer segments. Try doing this on one of the big carriers where you get a minimum of 500 miles for such a flight. You will never acquire a free ticket and you might as well forget about status. On WN there will be no status but at least you get a free ticket.