I certainly think Dividend Miles has every right to remove incorrectly awarded miles from a person's account, but to claim that a member was engaged in fraudulent activity just because he/she signed up for a "targeted" offer that was posted on FlyerTalk is beyond the pale. I've always simply assumed that such offers to me were "lost in the mail" or thrown out with the other junk mail, and that if I signed up for them based on FlyerTalk postings and the miles were credited to my account, then I must have been in the targeted group.