If you noticed, I haven't recommended Santorini, either (BTW, it's Oia, pronounced Ia- evidently, we don't do queues in Greece ). I've heard both good and bad things about it, but never been there and not on my list...If I'm going to an island and not mixing urban with sea holiday (as one can easily do in Corfu and probably in Rhodes, too), I might as well avoid the commercial disasters and go to a little, tranquil one with unspoilt beaches.