Originally Posted by
PTravel
Either they're bad units or you've mishandled them. I've had two miniDV camcorders and one HD miniDV camcorder. Never had the slightest problem with them, and I've been banging around the world with them, shooting hundreds of tapes.
Yes, that's what I was thinking. After all, most proffessional applications include a tape-based workflow, whether its just miniDV, DV, Beta, or DigiBeta. I shoot video semi-proffessionally and have used nothing but miniDV tapes on cameras such as the Sony Z1s and PD170s and they run years without problems. You will need to run a cleaning cassette through once in a while, though. My opinion stands that tape is still best for consumer applications although feel free to try out P2, SxS, CF, etc with the more expensive, reliable prosumer products.