We loved the Four Seasons, but I know that others here did not.
As far as I can remember:
The most often mentioned negatives are the steep hill (which I love because of the view and did not mind walking - or using the very efficient buggy service) and the food (lack of spices and price level - I would argue that one can just ask for the food to be spiced up + price level is normal FS price level). Positives are the excellent villas and very good service + SPA and kids club (if relevanbt). All villas have own pool. Some think that main pool is too small and some critizise the beach because one cannot swim there at low tide. We loved the beach and long to go back.